| Min | Event | Player | Team | Detail | Ref call |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1' | Yellow | Nicolò Savona | Nottingham Forest | Yellow Card | — |
| 2' | Goal | N. Milenkovic | Everton | Own Goal | — |
| 45' | Goal | T. Barry | Everton | Normal Goal | — |
| 45' | Yellow | Morato | Nottingham Forest | Yellow Card | — |
| 54' | Yellow | Nikola Milenković | Nottingham Forest | Yellow Card | — |
| 57' | Yellow | Thierno Barry | Everton | Yellow Card | — |
| 73' | Yellow | James Tarkowski | Everton | Yellow Card | — |
| 80' | Goal | K. Dewsbury-Hall | Everton | Normal Goal | — |
| 84' | Yellow | Vitaliy Mykolenko | Everton | Yellow Card | — |
| 90' | Yellow | Jake O'Brien | Everton | Yellow Card | — |