| Min | Event | Player | Team | Detail | Ref call |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18' | Goal | K. Mboma | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |
| 27' | Goal | G. Valenzuela | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |
| 33' | Goal |
| G. Castillo |
| FC Cincinnati |
| Own Goal |
| — |
| 35' | Goal | T. Barlow | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |
| 48' | Goal | A. Chavez | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |
| 58' | Goal | K. Mboma | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |
| 68' | Goal | S. Jimenez | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |
| 78' | Goal | A. Powell | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |
| 81' | Var | Héctor Ramírez | Universidad O&M | Card upgrade | — |
| 82' | Red | Héctor Ramírez | Universidad O&M | Red Card | — |
| 83' | Yellow | Sergio Abreu | Universidad O&M | Yellow Card | — |
| 86' | Goal | S. Chirila | FC Cincinnati | Normal Goal | — |