| Min | Event | Player | Team | Detail | Ref call |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5' | Penalty | V. Castellanos |
| New York City FC |
| Penalty |
| — |
| 30' | Goal | V. Castellanos | New York City FC | Normal Goal | — |
| 36' | Yellow | P. Arboine | Santos DE Guapiles | Yellow Card | — |
| 61' | Yellow | M. Barquero | Santos DE Guapiles | Yellow Card | — |
| 69' | Red | S. Rodriguez | New York City FC | Red Card | — |